“You’re quite hostile.”
“Hey man, I gotta right to be hostile, ‘cos my people are being persecuted.”
Public Enemy: ‘Prophets of Rage’.
“Just how does spouting hate speech about the opposition highlight the new [and better] politics you say you wish to establish?”
From a tweet of mine the other day:
Perhaps too often I am sarcastic – and too sarcastic at that.
I appreciate that sarcasm per se and my own sarcasm (usually an attempt at humour) is not always a nice thing.
Similarly, satire when done well, can be brilliant at exposing the pompous. It can reduce those we fear to figures of fun. It can go awry too.
During the referendum campaign we had much discussion of the CyberNat – the keyboard crusaders who were online to counter the media bias and stick it to the ‘No’ side. In my view, much of it was exaggerated but I accept that there were some examples of shocking online abuse to be found. [NB. The worst I got called was a ‘porridge gobbler’ from someone who suggested that Scotland was owned by the UK.]
We are now not only in the post-indyref period but also are in the period pre-indyref2.
How then, is that new Scotland, that presumably folks are still seeking, going to be won?
Will rage at the continuing injustice and inequality around us help?
To me, it depends on the target of this rage and the tactics used.
I recently saw a post about Kezia Dugdale that highlighted the first three letters in her surname.
Is this the new Scotland? Is this satire? Is this the level of debate in our society?
Are the people we wish to persuade in a future referendum simply to be blasted as ‘Red Tories’ because they still value their membership of the Labour party?
Surely, the best way is to focus any rage we have on developing a consensus for a better Scotland? Let our anger motivate us to find the solutions to the complex problems we face rather than resorting to sniping at others.
The challenge for the political parties that have ballooned in size since September is to channel the energy from their new recruits into positive optimism.
I do wonder though that when the digital activists move from campaigning on a cause to campaigning for an individual political party will we see that positivity?