Part 1: An Inspector Calls – or rather just texts.
Our school was inspected in the week beginning 28 September. We expected it and it had been preceded by a whole range of activities designed to tighten up our processes and practices, as well as the decor.
It struck me though; just how much of what we do is re-engineered to fit in with the apparent desires of the Inspectors? What happened to making things fit local needs and resources?
I wonder about the improvements that we made in the lead up to the inspection. Did they not serve to say to the pupils that they mattered less than our visitors?
I accept that the prospect of an inspection gets those things done that you had been planning but had not quite gotten around to doing. I wonder if it highlights that there are too many demands upon teachers and schools to get things done that are not directly beneficial to what we do?
My own experience of the inspection was minimal. I enjoyed only a brief conversation in the corridor with the team leader. I had an observation of an S1 class and was in a focus group on our school’s excellent work on Employability and, that was it.
This was a huge contrast with the last inspection. Indeed, maybe it was my experience of the previous inspection that protected me from excessive advanced fear of this one…
It felt less an inspection and more a fleeting visit. The previous inspection seemed like an operation without anaesthetic and this was a visit to the GP. I respect fully of course that the exercise was significantly different for those in our senior management team!
I was due to take part in a further focus group of Principal Teachers but I had to pull out as we had gotten word that my wife’s maternal grandfather was gravely ill.
Part 2: Death and Life, Failure and Hope
The final week of term was a mix of great highs and great lows.
On the Thursday there was the Dearest Scotland book launch. I had submitted my letter and backed the Kickstarter and this was when all the efforts put in by so many people came to fruition. It also meant that like a TeachMeet I got to meet some folks from my Twitter feed!
Despite being on or in a variety of media, there seems something very special about having your words appear in a book.
I wrote my letter on a Mac. I then emailed it before it was placed on the website and on my blog. At no point was it anything other than a set of 1s and 0s. But to hold a book and be able to point to a couple of pages that were written by me seemed to have a huge resonance.
Maybe this is why for years countless folks rushed out to get a copy of the local paper when their wee niece or grandson appeared in it. Is it better to have a clipping than to point at a webpage?
Who knows, maybe it is down to the possibility, decades from now of undertaking a re-run of the JR Hartley Yellow Pages ad?
The bounce I gained from that evening was huge but my fun was cut short just before 11 o’clock by a tweet from Frances Coppola:
“So sad. Greek mother and son find dead baby washed up on beach, say they will bury him as if he was a member of their own family.”
My Dearest Scotland letter focussed on meeting the needs of children today and future generations.
Yet, as I write the children of others are being washed up on shores within my continent. Their parents are demonised for wanting to escape from war or poverty.
What is it that allows us to put up with this continuing tragedy, or permits our leaders to pander to headlines rather than humanity?
It’s us. We allow it. It’s our failure.
It’s the same failure that meant that not long after that tweet and the sadness it brought I was back up to normal.
Or, maybe it’s just me.
I suffer from moodiness that can mean moving all-too-quickly from peaks to troughs and back again.
Indeed the regained positivity itself was cut short on the last morning of term by the sound of the phone ringing.
The news was that after being at death’s door the week before, and despite a recovery, a great man was now gone. This gave rise to many emotions: sadness that a life was at an end but gladness that his suffering and pain were now over.
The self-centred part of me also wondered just how to explain death to a 3-year-old. How to explain no more Great Granda cuddles and laughs. Maybe in this regard those that have faith have it a bit easier; death is not death, it’s not an end, it is simply a step to another and eternal life.
Even that pondering was forgotten with the ‘distraction’ of the working day. It was also helped by a man from Germany turning up to work at Anfield.
Like most Liverpool fans I have been swept up by the positivity, the hope generated by the appointment of Jürgen Klopp as manager. Time will tell if this turns out to be what is hoped – the start of something big, or if it is just a false dawn after so many others.
In this regard, football is like life. We celebrate the wins, despair at the losses and somehow manage to move on to the next game. Every season we start with renewed hope.
In school, it’s no different. Regardless of the exam results we start off with classes with hope. We hope we’ll do better, that pupils will learn more and enjoy greater success. Yet, there are set backs on the way. The class or student that doesn’t quite gel with you, the deadlines you can’t meet through workload and *horror* family ‘getting in the way’ or the myriad incidents, lessons or whatever that make up life as a teacher. We try to pick ourselves up, dust ourselves off and try again the next lesson.
We face the challenges of our own personal and our working lives. In doing so, we experience and are part of the lives of so many others: the pupil who has suffered bereavement in the same class as the pupil who has a new baby sister; the colleague under pressure and the one who has at long last got that promotion.
What is it that allows us to work through these things? One thing for sure is that it is getting harder for many teachers to do so.
I wonder, are we serious about teacher agency and autonomy? Will it be the reflection that teachers themselves undertake as well as those with colleagues and pupils that determine next steps? Or will we be continuing to wait for an external agency to come and visit? Worse still, will the government press ahead with the utter stupidity of a new form of standardised testing?
What is it that allows us to put up with these things, or permits our leaders to pander to headlines rather than pedagogy?
Will it be us? Will we allow it? If so, will it will be our failure, when we face so many challenges just to get by?
Maybe if the work of inspectors was re-engineered to fit the desires of schools and teachers and the pupils they served.
Maybe if workload and our contr(actual) obligations matched what we were paid to do.
Maybe if the focus was on meeting the needs of pupils rather than them or us jumping through hoops or ticking boxes our schools would be places where hope blossomed.